Get the exclusive (almost) Weekly Digest.

    Educational Philosophy, Home Education, Mother's Education

    Teaching Math When You’re not a Numbers Person

    April 15, 2015 by Brandy Vencel

    The human mind is essentially one,
    but the directions it may take are many,
    and it is easy to see that people in general divide
    into those with a bent toward numbers and science
    and those who take naturally to literature, history, and the arts.

    -Jacques Barzun, Begin Here

    I suppose if I must choose, I will say that I am a literature, history, and arts person — that I am not a numbers person. I disliked math until about age ten, when it started to make sense to me. After that, I rather enjoyed it. But I always needed a good teacher or tutor, being disinclined to figure it out for myself. I was not a natural “numbers person.”

    Teaching Math when You're not a Numbers Person

    It’s easy for those of us who are not numbers people to get a little nervous about teaching math in our homeschools. Math was hard, we might say, and so who are we to think we could teach it?

    While it’s true that we need to know and understand math in order to teach it, it is not true, it turns out, that only numbers people can teach math. In fact, Jacques Barzun rather questions the idea:

    [T]he mind that feels at home with math is likely to lack the qualities that make a good teacher.

    The way he explains it makes loads of sense. To numbers people, certain things are obvious which are emphatically Not Obvious to the rest of us. Numbers people often make great leaps when they try to instruct others (because, to them, the leaps are obvious), and these leaps leave gaps in understanding for the average not-a-numbers person.

    [O]mitting assumptions in teaching will produce in the student mind a gap in understanding that may last for years.

    My guess is that a numbers person teaching a not-a-numbers person is much worse than a numbers person teaching another numbers person. The latter just might make giant leaps together and enjoy it immensely.

    The problem Barzun is addressing lies in the fact that math teachers have to talk aloud — they have to explain what they are doing in words a student can understand. And since they are not words people, this tends to get them into trouble, especially when we’re talking about the rare situation of an extreme numbers person trying to teach something like elementary arithmetic.

    But the point of this post is not to debate whether or not a numbers person could successfully teach math to a not-a-numbers student. Rather, it’s to encourage those of you who are discouraged by the fact that you are not a numbers person.

    What do you need to have in order to be a good teacher? Barzun says that first, you have to have enough smarts to be baffled by Eduspeak. You know. That secret language they use at Teachers College? That’s what he’s talking about — that made-up language spoken only by experts.

    Next, you need to have “a strong interest in some branch of learning.” Even better, a lot of branches. That’s his third criteria: interests beyond a particular specialty. Learn stuff, says Barzun:

    In bearing, in manner of thinking and talking, a teacher should quite naturally appear to be a person with a mental life, a person who reads books…

     

    Imagine that. He’s prescribing scholĂ©, or Mother Culture.

    So. You’re not a numbers person? It’s okay. Barzun says you can teach math anyhow. In fact, it might be to your advantage because

    teaching is par excellence the adaptation of one particular mind to another

    and who can understand the child struggling with math better than one who struggled with the same thing, once upon a time? You have the compassion necessary to reach out to the child and help him along. Couple that with a decent curriculum, and you’re good to go.

     

    Get the (almost) weekly digest!

    Weekly encouragement, direct to your inbox, (almost) every Saturday.

    Powered by Kit

    23 Comments

    Leave a Reply